News

First female genital mutilation trial held after 13-year-old Egyptian girl killed

First female genital mutilation trial held after 13-year-old Egyptian girl killed
Mutilacao-Genital-Feminina
This photograph was taken by CNN in 1996 and showed a 10-year-old being mutilated at a barbershop in Cairo

By Abeer Salah, Aswat Masriya

An Egyptian court postponed on Thursday the female genital mutilation trial of a doctor who had preformed the surgery on a teenage girl that led to her to death to June 19. 

Sohair al-Bata’a, 13, died in June 2013 at Raslan Halawa’s private medical clinic while undergoing an FGM operation at her father’s request, who is also standing trial.  

“The story unfolded when the victim’s father filed a complaint, accusing the doctor of killing his daughter after performing an FGM operation,” said Mona Amin, the general coordinator of National Population Council’s national project for banning FGM.

This is the first trial of its kind since Egypt banned the practice in 2008. 

Outrage causes investigation

Sohair al-Bata'a, the 13-year-old girl who died after undergoing FGM
Sohair al-Bata’a, the 13-year-old girl who died after undergoing FGM

The investigation was pushed for by the National Population Council (NPC) last November, which demanded establishing a committee of forensic experts to verify the real cause of death, stated Amin.’

During investigation, the father retracted from his initial police report statements accusing the doctor, instead, he claimed his daughter was suffering from pelvic pain, and was diagnosed of having “excess” skin that had to be removed through a doctor.

Halawa has denied carrying out FGM. Instead, he stated that the victim suffered from “excess” skin which he had removed by cauterization. He insisted that she died because of an allergic reaction to the anesthetic medication.

The coroner, assigned by the Public Prosecution, held the doctor responsible for failing to test Bata’a for allergic reactions. However, he reported that medical intervention to remove “excess” skin was “right”.

Based on the results of the investigation, the doctor was charged with wrongful death. He was also charged, along with the father, with performing FGM and referred to trial.

The punishment for performing FGM is a prison sentence ranging from three months to two years or a fine of 5,000 Egyptian pounds.

At least 91 percent of Egyptian females in the age group 15-49 have undergone FGM, according to the 2008 census. Although doctors now perform 70 percent of these operations, traditional midwives and health barbers usually carried out the practice.

Egypt's 'beacon of hope' behind steel bars
Only An Egyptian Girl Will Struggle For An Education Like This

Subscribe to our newsletter


  • Pingback: Egyptian doctor sentenced to prison after 13-year-old dies from female genital mutilation | Egyptian Streets()

  • Pingback: Doctor acquitted after 13-year-old Egyptian girl dies from female genital mutilation | Egyptian Streets()

  • Bystanding Witness

    What is so difficult in enforcing our existing laws and maybe more important for the Muslim citizens of society – why don’t you respect the Fatwa by Al Azhar of 2006 that OUTLAWS FGM as NOT being in line with the teachings of the Qur’an!?!?! What is so difficult to understand?
    The very same goes for the Christian citizens of society – it is AGAINST the teachings of the Bible too!!
    PLEASE STOP mutilating your girls = future wifes and mothers of your children!!!

  • Maria Cirillo

    When will people understand that no man can change what God made??? God made us perfect, who are we to change God`s biggest creation? This kind of practices (For men AND women) should be considered the real sin!!!

  • Vanessa

    Pelvic pain? Has this man ever heard of PMS? Jeez … Excess skin. What a joke. This practice needs to be stopped.

  • I can only hope Egyptian Legislation will approve a more severe punishment for FGM. Egypt should lead the way in showing the rest of the world, where this practice is still carried out, that this is totally unacceptable in modern Egypt and the rest of the world. May the soul of this young girl rest in peace.
    Dr Mustapha Tahir
    @MustaphaTahir

News
@AswatMasriya_En

Aswat Masriya is a Thomson Reuters Foundation-sponsored website that covers Egypt's transition to democracy. en.aswatmasriya.com

More in News

05black

Egypt’s Foreign Reserves Rise to $US 23 Billion

Egyptian StreetsDecember 6, 2016
1200x-1-1024x697-1

Naguib Sawiris Steps Down as CEO of Orascom in Surprise Resignation

Egyptian StreetsDecember 6, 2016
One of the leaked images allegedly from a Heinz Egypt factory.

Senior Heinz Egypt Employee Arrested After 62 Tonnes of Rotten Tomatoes Found

Egyptian StreetsDecember 6, 2016
sticlute-de-parfum-2

Import Tariffs on 320 Goods Increased by up to 60 Percent in Egypt

Aswat MasriyaDecember 5, 2016
One of the leaked images allegedly from a Heinz Egypt factory.

‘Disgusting Video’ of Ketchup Production Called Misleading by Heinz Egypt

Egyptian StreetsDecember 4, 2016
squashwomen

Egypt’s Women Make Squash History Taking Top Three Spots in World Ranking

Egyptian StreetsDecember 4, 2016
Protesters gather to demonstrate Egypt's decision to declare two Red Sea islands as Saudi Arabian. Khaled Ali, pictured, brought a case to the Administrative Court against the decision. Credit: Belal Darder

Egypt’s Constitutional Court Rules Against Interior Minister Authority to Ban Protests

Aya NaderDecember 3, 2016
pablo-4

Egypt’s Foreign Minister in ‘First Meeting’ Between Arab Official and US Vice President-elect

Egyptian StreetsDecember 1, 2016
Egyptian Streets is an independent, young, and grass roots news media organization aimed at providing readers with an alternate depiction of events that occur on Egyptian and Middle Eastern streets, and to establish an engaging social platform for readers to discover and discuss the various issues that impact the region.

© 2016 ES Media UG. All Rights Reserved.