Opinion

Trump’s Immigration Ban Will Not Stop Terrorism

Trump’s Immigration Ban Will Not Stop Terrorism

President Donald Trump speaks following the ceremonial swearing-in of James Mattis as secretary of defense at the Pentagon in Washington, on Jan. 27, 2017. Mandel Ngan—AFP/Getty Images

By imposing a blanket ban on immigration for selected countries and suspending the U.S. Refugee program, Donald Trump will not effectively counter the threat of a terrorist attack on American soil, nor will he ‘Make America Safe Again’.

Executive orders, immigration bans, airport protests and the firing of the Acting Attorney-General have punctuated what has been a tumultuous past few days in the United States of America. In his second week of presidency, Donald Trump has caused much consternation amongst the global community.

Under the guise of fighting what he calls ‘Radical Islamic Terrorism’, Trump’s executive order temporarily banning citizens of seven Middle-Eastern and African countries from entering the United States has been subject to intense scrutiny as it continues to cause severe disruption for families  caught in this immigration debacle.

Named ‘Protecting the Nation from Foreign Terrorist Entry into the United States’, Executive Order 13769 also suspends the United States Refugee Admissions Program for 120 days, fulfilling a campaign promise Trump made in 2016.

Questions have already arisen in relation to Trump’s selection of countries which have made the immigration ban list. Alex Nowrasteh from the Cato Institute astonishingly finds that no terrorist attacks were committed by nationals on the immigration ban list between 1975 and 2015. In fact, the death toll for Americans killed by Syrian refugees in terrorist attacks on American soil is zero.

Interestingly, Saudi Arabia does not make the list. This is despite Trump himself calling Saudi Arabia “the world’s biggest funders of terrorism”. Fifteen of the 19 Al-Qaeda affiliated hijackers in the 9/11 attacks, which killed 2,977 people, were Saudi citizens. Moreover, it is no secret that Saudi Arabia remains the bastion and main exporter of militant Wahhabism – a destructive ideology that promotes a literal, puritanical and ultraconservative firebrand version of Islam.

History is rife with examples of pernicious Saudi interference in the Muslim world as the Kingdom has spread its Wahhabi tentacles, funding extremist groups such as the Taliban in the Afghanistan since the Soviet-Afghan War and radical militants fighting in the Syrian Civil War.

According to the United Nations High Commissioner for Refugees (UNHCR), 4.8 million have fled to Turkey, Lebanon, Jordan, Egypt and Iraq, and 6.6 million are internally displaced within Syria.

Reports have already emerged remarking that the travel restrictions imposed by the executive order omits countries where Trump maintains business interests. This may also explain Qatar’s absence from the immigration ban despite evidence of the Gulf state sponsoring terrorism in Syria.

Trump’s inclusion of Iran in the immigration ban list also serves to satisfy the Saudis (and the Qataris) as the Saudi-Iranian battle for supremacy across the Middle-East continues across Syrian and Yemeni fronts. The inconsistency between Trump’s rhetoric and his actions is all the more apparent when one considers Saudi Arabia has recently pledged its support for Trump’s idea to establish safe zones in Syria and Yemen. So much for confronting state sponsors of terrorism.

Pakistan also remains a dubious omission from the travel restrictions imposed although the idea of the country being included in the future is being considered. Pakistan’s continual express and covert financial, logistical, military and intelligence support for Taliban, especially through its notorious secret service, the ISI, is no secret.

From 2001 to 2016, the US had spent $US 783bn in Afghanistan – much of this dedicated to fighting a Pakistani-backed Taliban. Given the atrocities Afghans have suffered in the past under Taliban rule and indiscriminate civilian attacks in the ongoing Taliban insurgency, it is strikingly odd to see Pakistan missing from the list. Meanwhile an impoverished nation like Yemen with 18.8 million people in need somehow makes Trump’s cut.

It appears Trump is genuinely uninterested in effectively combating terrorism or protecting America. By imposing these ridiculous travel bans and suspending the Refugee Program, the executive order effectively targets the main victims of terrorism. Iraqis, Syrians and more recently Yemenis, have suffered the most at the hands of terrorist groups and yet it is citizens of these countries who will indiscriminately be denied entry into the United States.

The order also places the United States in breach of its obligations under the 1967 Protocol Relating to the Status of Refugees. Obligations in relation to the imposition of penalties or restrictions on the movement of refugees (Article 31) and non-refoulement (Article 33) are clearly violated. Refugees fleeing the horrors of violence and persecution, whether at the hands of non-state terrorist groups like ISIS or by Assad’s barrel bombs in Syria, will be forced back to their doom.

Whilst Trump’s executive order serves to placate the interests of the far-right and the emerging alt-right who have hilariously dubbed the refugee crisis an invasion, the damaging consequences of this policy on people have been real.

Ironically, the immigration ban only serves to make America more vulnerable to attacks rather than ‘safe again’. Groups like ISIS and Al-Qaeda are salivating at these recent developments as the executive order will almost certainly be used for propaganda purposes to reinforce the extremist narrative that America and the West are at war with Islam.

No one denies that domestic security measures should be taken to address the global terrorism phenomenon. But a blanket immigration ban and the suspension of the Refugee Program does nothing to alleviate the threat of terrorism especially when existing screening measures for refugees appear to be both rigorous and effective.

The consequences of Trump’s recent executive order remain yet to be fully realised. Besides devastating civilians and their families, and perhaps rejuvenating terrorist groups, any other positive effect on national security or counter-terrorism is so far both imperceptible and inconceivable.

Chasing Dreams on the Desert Road: Moving From Alexandria to Cairo
'We Are Poor': 7 Costly Things Egypt Could Have Done Without

Subscribe to our newsletter


Opinion

Musood Darwish is an Australian law student studying a Juris Doctor at the University of Sydney where he is an affiliate of the Sydney Centre for International Law. Currently, he works at the University of Sydney Business School. He previously completed a Bachelor of Commerce majoring in Finance and Economics. His key interest areas include Middle-Eastern history, conflicts and foreign policy as well as international relations. Other areas of his concern include systems of government and humanitarian issues in Middle-East.

More in Opinion

Mubarak Died Long Ago

Amro AliMarch 25, 2017

Celebrity Visits Create a Shift in the Equilibrium of Egyptian Tourism

Egyptian StreetsMarch 17, 2017

What Egypt’s New Capital City Can Learn from Singapore

Mirna Khaled AbdulaalFebruary 26, 2017

What Devaluing the Egyptian Pound Really Means for Many of Us

Muhammad HazemFebruary 20, 2017

Cairo Confessions: Girls and the Hell of Premarital Physical Intimacy in Egypt

Toqa EzzidinFebruary 18, 2017

The New York Times and the Muslim Brotherhood

Nervana MahmoudFebruary 14, 2017

How Did Trump’s Muslim Ban Affect Egyptians

Mohanad ElsangaryFebruary 8, 2017

Chasing Dreams on the Desert Road: Moving From Alexandria to Cairo

Farah TawfeekFebruary 2, 2017
Egyptian Streets is an independent, young, and grass roots news media organization aimed at providing readers with an alternate depiction of events that occur on Egyptian and Middle Eastern streets, and to establish an engaging social platform for readers to discover and discuss the various issues that impact the region.

© 2017 ES Media UG. All Rights Reserved.