Buzz

Jay-Z, Timbaland in Court for ‘Stealing Music’ from Egyptian Composer Baligh Hamdy

Jay-Z, Timbaland in Court for ‘Stealing Music’ from Egyptian Composer Baligh Hamdy

FotorCreated

By Maha AbdelAzim

Rappers Jay-Z and Timbaland testified in a Los Angeles federal court on Wednesday over charges that they had illegally sampled the work of Egyptian composer Baligh Hamdy in their 1999 hit, “Big Pimpin’.”

Osama Fahmy, Hamdy’s nephew and the inheritor of the copyrights interest, raised the lawsuit in 2007 and claimed that the rappers sampled the 1960s song “Khosara Khosara” – famously sung by Abdel Halim Hafez – without the permission of the author’s family, which has the exclusive rights to grant the required license.

Jay-Z and Timbaland, whose real names are Shawn Carter and Timothy Mosley, admitted to using Hamdy’s melody in their song but claim they got the rights to play the melody from the record label EMI Music Arabia for the rights to play the song anywhere outside Egypt.

Timbaland, who produced “Big Pimpin’,” first used Hamdy’s melody based on the belief that it was in the public domain and could be used freely without licensing. Upon finding out this was not the case, he paid $100,000 to the record label EMI Music Arabia for the rights to play the song anywhere outside Egypt.

The rappers therefore claimed that Fahmy was only looking for “undeserved income” by raising the lawsuit.

However, the lawsuit is based on the legal distinction between economic rights – an author’s right to receive financial compensation for the use of their works – and moral rights. These are an author’s right to preserve their moral bond with their work by approving or denying any potential derivatives or modifications to it by other authors, even those who have acquired economic rights.

Moral rights are clearly recognized under Egyptian law, though much less so under US law.

While the lawsuit also claims that EMI Arabia did not have the right to sublicense the song for use by the defendants, it also relies heavily on the concept of moral rights. Fahmy claims that Hamdy’s family has the exclusive right to approve the particular derivative of the song used in “Big Pimpin’.”

Fahmy’s lawyer also claims that the defendants deliberately avoided requesting this approval, knowing that it would be rejected due to the “vulgar” and “disgusting” lyrics of the song.

However, since the legal debate is the authors’ rights themselves and not how they would have been used, the lyrics themselves are irrelevant and will not be considered in the trial as they could potentially prejudice the jury against the defendants.

Jay-Z, who is famously married to singer Beyoncé Knowles, also previously requested to keep his wealth – an estimated $560 million – out of the trial proceedings to avoid a biased jury.

Egyptians to be Fined EGP 500 for not Voting in Parliamentary Elections
Sisi Calls on Egyptians to 'Line Up Outside Polling Stations'

Subscribe to our newsletter


Buzz

More in Buzz

Moonlight’s Mahershala Ali Becomes First Muslim Actor Ever to Win an Oscar

Aya NaderFebruary 27, 2017

Searching for Life Quality? Cairo, Alexandria Just Made It to Africa’s Top 10 Cities

Aya NaderFebruary 23, 2017

#StopTheWait: Messi Visits Egypt to Promote Affordable Hepatitis C Treatment and Tourism

Egyptian StreetsFebruary 22, 2017

‘Egypt is the Most Fascinating Place on Earth’: How to Spend Just 48 Hours in Egypt

Egyptian StreetsFebruary 14, 2017

Drinking Liquor Without Getting Drunk Not Sinful: Islamic Scholar

Egyptian StreetsFebruary 13, 2017

World’s Heaviest Woman Transported from Egypt to India for Weight Reduction Surgery

Toqa EzzidinFebruary 13, 2017

Egypt is the Cheapest Place in the World to Buy a Big Mac – But What Does That Mean?

Mohamed KhairatJanuary 31, 2017

Meet Dina Habib Powell, the Egyptian-American Appointed by Trump to the White House

Mohamed KhairatJanuary 17, 2017
Egyptian Streets is an independent, young, and grass roots news media organization aimed at providing readers with an alternate depiction of events that occur on Egyptian and Middle Eastern streets, and to establish an engaging social platform for readers to discover and discuss the various issues that impact the region.

© 2017 ES Media UG. All Rights Reserved.